Winning Idea Pty Ltd · Unit 4 · behind the carpet warehouse

WinningIdea.com

We take your idea. We look at it. Then we stop. This is a consultancy in the same way a moth is a board member.

Filed March 12, 2026 · correspondence

The Spider

A client asked for a pitch deck. I sent a drawing of a spider and an invoice for looking at their problem.

Fig. 1 — Deliverable. The unlabeled legs are still in discovery.
From:
Dana Ellison <dana@northforksynergy.com>
To:
Gareth Winning <gareth@winningidea.com>
Date:
Mon, 9 Mar 2026 09:14
Subject:
Urgent — one-pager + deck by Friday

Gareth —

Great connecting last week. As discussed, we need a one-pager and a 12-slide deck positioning Northfork as the regional leader in “human-centered gravel.” Friday EOD is hard. Brand guidelines attached (48MB). Please use the approved teal.

Dana

From:
Gareth Winning <gareth@winningidea.com>
To:
Dana Ellison <dana@northforksynergy.com>
Date:
Fri, 13 Mar 2026 16:41
Subject:
Re: Urgent — one-pager + deck by Friday

Dana,

Please find attached a drawing of a spider. I have labeled one of the legs “synergy” and another “gravel,” which I feel covers the brief.

I did not use the teal. The teal made me tired.

Invoice for four hours of looking is in the second attachment. The looking was of a high standard.

Gareth Winning

Director of Winning

Winning Idea

From:
Dana Ellison <dana@northforksynergy.com>
To:
Gareth Winning <gareth@winningidea.com>
Date:
Fri, 13 Mar 2026 16:47
Subject:
Re: Urgent — one-pager + deck by Friday

Gareth this is a JPEG of a spider. It is not a deck. There are no slides. One of the legs is just a line that goes off the page.

Also the invoice is for $2,400.

From:
Gareth Winning <gareth@winningidea.com>
To:
Dana Ellison <dana@northforksynergy.com>
Date:
Fri, 13 Mar 2026 17:02
Subject:
Re: Urgent — one-pager + deck by Friday

The line that goes off the page is the part of the strategy you cannot see yet. That is called vision.

I can convert the spider into twelve slides if you would like. Each slide will be a closer crop of a different leg. Please advise if you have a preferred leg.

The invoice remains.

Gareth

From:
Dana Ellison <dana@northforksynergy.com>
To:
Gareth Winning <gareth@winningidea.com>
Date:
Mon, 16 Mar 2026 08:03
Subject:
We will not be paying this

We showed the spider in the Monday standup. Two people clapped because they thought it was a joke. One person asked if we were being sued.

Please void the invoice.

From:
Gareth Winning <gareth@winningidea.com>
To:
Dana Ellison <dana@northforksynergy.com>
Date:
Mon, 16 Mar 2026 11:19
Subject:
Re: We will not be paying this

I will not void the invoice. Clapping is a metric. Confusion is also a metric. You have two metrics, which is more than most of my clients.

I have attached a second spider. This one is sitting down, to indicate listening.

Gareth Winning

Winning Idea — “Ideas that refuse to work”

Northfork Synergy later launched a campaign called GRAVEL FEELS. It did not use a spider. It also did not use teal. I take no credit and all of it.

← Index